This is intended to be an objective summary; I don’t necessarily recommend all of these methods. My goal is to lay out all the different ways people walk dogs on lead.
Guiding principles:
1. Once you find a method you like, stick with it. Consistency will help your dog.
2. Good leadership goes a long way. The leadership concept is addressed more in other training materials.
A. “Management” Techniques… letting the equipment do the work.
1. Gentle Leader (Head Halter)
Notes:
- Same concept as walking a horse.
- Contrary to some misconceptions, dogs can still breathe, drink, eat, etc.
- Make sure you follow the instructions/fit the head halter properly.
Pros:
- Gentle.
- Effective.
Cons:
- Dog may not like having on its head at first.
- May require time to get dog used to it.
2. No-pull Body Harness (Front Clasp)
Notes:
- Works well for some dogs – others will still pull. Just try and see.
- Make sure you follow the instructions/fit the harness properly.
Pros:
- A body harness under tension is gentler/safer than a neck collar under tension.
Cons:
- May rub skin. Note: hemp material may be gentler on the skin.
3. Prong Collar
Notes:
- For your own safety, make sure your dog is calm while you put the prong collar on and take it off.
Pros:
- Some dogs will do anything to avoid those prongs.
Cons:
- Some dogs will still pull and they could be injured.
B. Teach a traditional “Heel” – dog’s shoulder next to your leg.
1. Reward in position
Notes:
- Use tiny, soft, healthy treats.
- Dogs are precise learners. Reward exactly what you like.
- Clicker training is recommended. The clicker concept is addressed more in other training materials.
Pros:
- Gentle.
- Effective.
- Teaching strengthens leadership position.
- Positive reinforcement strengthens trust.
- Doesn’t matter how you’re “attached” – collar, harness, etc.
Cons:
- Treat prep time.
- Have to carry treats.
- May require practice to get person used to handling treats.
2. Correct wrong position (hand poke, collar correction (choker, prong, shock))
Notes:
- Highly handler dependent.
- Formal training recommended.
- Stop immediately if you are feeling emotional.
- Can be combined with reward in position.
Pros:
- Some dogs will do anything to avoid the correction.
- If done effectively, teaching strengthens leadership position.
- If done effectively, can tap natural herding/body blocking instincts.
Cons:
- Overly harsh corrections hurt trust.
- Sloppy, confusing corrections hurt trust.
- More fun for dog to learn what to do, rather than learn what not to do.
C. Teach a “Loose Lead” walk – do not follow when the dog pulls.
1. Walk when loose; don’t walk when tight.
Notes:
- Dogs are precise learners.
- Stop exactly when it gets tight.
- Method can be enhanced:
- Make a certain sound to indicate too tight.
- Turn and reward in the other direction.
Pros:
- Gentle.
- Teaching strengthens leadership position.
- Positive reinforcement strengthens trust.
- Doesn’t matter how you’re “attached” – collar, harness, etc.
Cons:
- If you are not precise and consistent, it will take longer for the dog to catch on.